May 2003
The Mutual Fund Fee Problem—Part 2
In last month’s Wisconsin Energy Cooperative
News, I focused on “no-load” mutual funds and the
importance of determining how much you are really paying in
mutual fund expenses because it will make a tremendous difference
on how much you really earn on your invested funds.
This month I turn my attention to “load” mutual
funds. Load funds also charge fees. Some of the fees are paid
up front based on the total amount you are investing and some
fees are paid for part—or over the life of—your
investment. These fees eat into your returns and should be a
very important consideration when investing your hard-earned
funds.
There are generally three different types of “load”
funds. First, there are “A” shares where you pay
your broker an up-front sales charge, or load, that is subtracted
from your up-front investment. The loads usually are reduced
the more you invest. Second, there are “B” shares
where you do not pay an up-front sale charge. However, the mutual
fund company pays the broker’s commission and you then
pay the mutual fund company the amount of the commission over
time through higher fees. The redemption fees falls the longer
you keep your investment. Third, there are “C” shares
that usually do not charge an up-front sales or redemption fee.
In return, you are charged higher annual costs for the life
of your investment.
Add to this the so-called “break points” where you
receive certain up-front sales discounts or price breaks depending
on how much you have invested.
Confused? Unfortunately, many Americans are confused about load
funds. Hopefully your broker remembers you are paying fees for
advice, and that advice should direct you towards the lowest-cost
shares. Furthermore, your mutual fund prospectus is required
to illustrate the impact different share-class fees will have
on a $10,000 investment over various time frames. The prospectus
must also list, but unfortunately does not demonstrate, the
impact of break points.
According to the Wall Street Journal, mutual funds offer brokers
marketing materials that outline the advantages of one share
class over another, but this material isn’t normally provided
to investors. I have found my own broker to be quite willing
to work through the math with me, but I have heard from other
consumers that their broker provided little or no explanation
before they invested. You may need to investigate fees on your
own. The National Association of Securities Dealers (www.nasdr.com/FundCalc/expense_analyzers.asp)
and the Securities and Exchange Commission (www.sec.gov/investor/tools/mfcc/mfcc-int.htm)
provide fund cost calculators. Both sites also helpfully allow
you to check to see whether any regulatory or disciplinary action
has been taken by the federal or state government against your
broker.
Next month, I plan to discuss unauthorized buying club charges
on credit card accounts.